The First Alert SC5 is the closest thing to a successor for the Nest Protect, and for many households it is the easiest smart alarm to recommend. It combines a photoelectric smoke sensor with an electrochemical CO sensor and uses First Alert's Precision Detection technology, which the company says is designed to meet updated standards for early warning and fewer nuisance alarms, such as those triggered by cooking. The product page lists compliance with the UL 217 10th Edition standard.
When something is wrong, the SC5 speaks: voice alerts with a Heads-Up warning name the type of danger and its location in the home, and the First Alert app sends mobile notifications whether you are home or away. Alarms interconnect wirelessly, so when one sounds, compatible alarms elsewhere in the house sound as well. That compatibility explicitly includes Google Nest Protect units, which means you can replace aging Protects one at a time without breaking your existing network.
The battery version runs on replaceable CR123A lithium cells and warns you in the app before they run low, which removes the classic late-night chirp. First Alert backs it with a 10-year limited warranty. The main caveats are that CR123A batteries cost more than AA cells, and if you rely on the Nest Protect pathway, setup runs through the Google Home app and a Google account. A hardwired SC5 is also sold for homes with existing alarm wiring.
| Sensors | Photoelectric smoke + electrochemical CO |
|---|---|
| Sound level | 85 dB at 10 ft |
| Power | Replaceable CR123A lithium batteries |
| Standard | UL 217 10th Edition |
| Interconnect | Wireless with First Alert and Google Nest Protect alarms |
| Warranty | 10-year limited |
- Combination smoke and CO detection in one alarm
- Voice alerts name the hazard and the room
- Wireless interconnect, including with Google Nest Protect
- App alerts for emergencies and low batteries
- No wiring needed for the battery model
- 10-year limited warranty
- CR123A batteries are pricier than standard AA cells
- Nest Protect integration requires the Google Home app and account